Free signup + 7 days PRO included Create my account

PHI @ NYM MLB prediction: AI analysis & picks

MLB — Regular Season
PHIPHI
PHI
Away
★Follow
Aaron NolaRCONFIRMED
xERA 4.11
Last 5 WLWLL
3 — 0
FINAL
2026-09-17
NYMNYM
NYM
Home
★Follow
Nolan McLeanRCONFIRMED
xERA 3.62
Last 5 LLLLW
Analysis published before first pitch Time-stamped odds (CLV) Transparent methodology
First 5 · 4.5 1.94
Full Time — +0.5open 7.5
Run line · -1.5 2.60
Multi-bookmaker odds · time-stamped

Our picks for this match

AI Trend UNDER 4.5
Model confidence53 %
Odds
1.94
Market
First 5 Innings (F5)
Taken on 17/09 · 18:28 at odds of 1.94
Official pick NYM -1.5
Model confidence41 %
Odds
2.60
Market
Run Line (Spread)
Suggested stake
1.5 u Kelly ↗
Taken on 17/09 · 13:12 at odds of 2.60
AI Trend No run in the 1st inning (NRFI)
Model confidence55 %
Odds
1.93
Market
First Inning (NRFI/YRFI)
Taken on 17/09 · 00:34 at odds of 1.93

Our Expert Analysis

PRO
Confidence
70%
Starters xERA4.11 vs 3.62PHI (away) · NYM (home)
View full analysis

PROBABLE STARTERS

● Home: Nolan McLean (RHP) — xERA 3.71
● Away: Aaron Nola (RHP) — xERA 4.07
● Run Line: Mets -1.5 @ 2.600 — Confidence 50% (official)

GAME CONTEXT

The Philadelphia Phillies (84-68) travel to Citi Field for a late-season NL East showdown against the New York Mets (69-83). Philly arrives on the heels of a clean 3-0 road win in Washington, while New York has dropped four straight. In their most recent head-to-head series at Citizens Bank Park in July, the Mets took two of three.

KEY ABSENCES

● Home (NYM): Cionel Perez (RP), Daniel Duarte (RP), Devin Williams (RP) + 4 long-term IL
● Away (PHI): Caleb Kilian (RP), Jesus Luzardo (SP), Adolis Garcia (RF) + 3 long-term IL

GAME SCRIPT

Through the first five innings, McLean holds a meaningful xERA edge — 3.71 versus 4.07 for Nola — and draws a Phillies lineup that strikes out at a 0.212 rate against opposing starters, well above the Mets' 0.165. Nola was solid enough on September 11 (6.1 IP, 2 ER), but New York's lineup posts a .349 wOBA against starting pitching compared to just .288 for Philadelphia, giving the home side the clearer offensive upside. When both starters hand off to their bullpens, the gap widens further in New York's favor: a 4.89 ERA over the last 14 days versus a 5.83 mark for the Philly relief corps. Conditions are benign — 78°F, 7 mph wind — and a 0.95 park factor tilts slightly toward pitching.

OUR ANALYSIS

The Mets -1.5 run line is supported by three converging factors: McLean's xERA advantage over Nola against a Philadelphia lineup that K's heavily (0.212) and posts a low wOBA vs. starters (.288); a clear bullpen edge for New York (94 ERA points better over 14 days); and pitcher-friendly conditions at a sub-1.00 park. At 2.600 with 50% confidence, this is a measured edge — size your bet proportionally to your bankroll.

Devil's advocate

McLean's last start is a genuine red flag: 5.0 IP, 5 ER, 10 H on September 11 — a performance that sits sharply at odds with his xERA and signals real vulnerability in current form. Philadelphia is the better team by record (84-68 vs. 69-83), and the Mets enter riding a four-game losing streak with no momentum. If Nola — who delivered 7.0 IP and 1 ER in two of his last five outings — repeats that performance, the Phillies could hold a lead narrow enough to limit the damage. That said, protecting any advantage with a 5.83 ERA bullpen is a shaky proposition for Philadelphia. We accept the risk.

ProbWin verdict

McLean's xERA edge and a superior Mets bullpen are the twin pillars of this play. The Mets -1.5 run line is a measured opportunity — back it with a proportional stake.

Key Factors

Pitcher hand
RvsR
F5 Over%
47.1%vs50.0%
FT Over%
50.0%vs50.0%
F5 Signal
—vs—
Full access to the analysis

Unlock all picks and the full analysis

The verdict on every market, the full written analysis, absences, referee stats and the best price from around ten bookmakers — no commitment.

Trial
7 days
Free
Get started →
No credit card
POPULAR
Day Pass
2,99€
24h access
Unlock today →
No renewal
PRO
19€/mo
All picks
See pricing →
1-click cancel

Secure Stripe payment — Analysis independent from the betting market

Head-to-Head

2PHI
NYM3
07/19/26NYM @ PHI6 – 1
07/18/26NYM @ PHI1 – 6
07/16/26NYM @ PHI4 – 1
06/28/26PHI @ NYM5 – 4
06/27/26PHI @ NYM2 – 6

Form & Stats

Team Comparison

5 of 39 model features (last 5-10 games)

PHI STAT NYM
4.11
Starter xERA ? Nolan McLean vs Aaron Nola — ERA attendue basée sur la qualité des contacts
3.62
84.1
Exit Velocity ? Vitesse de sortie de balle au contact (mph) — qualité du contact offensif
83.1
8
HR (3 matchs) ? Home Runs sur les 3 derniers matchs — puissance récente
4
6.27
Bullpen ERA ? ERA du bullpen sur 14 jours — points mérités par les releveurs
5.28
89.8
Vélocité moy. ? Vélocité moyenne des lancers rencontrés (mph) — calibre des adversaires affrontés
90.0
Recent Results
PHI
DateGameScore
09/16@ WSN3-0
09/15@ WSN3-6
09/13@ ATL9-4
09/12@ ATL2-12
09/11@ ATL5-6
NYM
DateGameScore
09/16vs BAL1-7
09/15vs BAL5-7
09/14vs BAL1-2
09/13@ NYY0-2
09/12@ NYY12-2
Pitcher impact on totals
PitcherStartsF5 vs LineF5 Over%F5 SignalFT vs LineFT Over%FT Signal
Aaron Nola (AWAY)17-0.0947.1%-0.0050.0%-
Nolan McLean (HOME)160.3450.0%-0.0050.0%-
Last 5 starts
Aaron Nola (PHI)
DatevsIPERHBBKERA
09/26TBR1.00340027.00
09/23MIL6.0044186.00
09/17NYM7.0003340.00
09/11ATL6.3326332.84
09/06ATL7.0014151.29
Nolan McLean (NYM)
DatevsIPERHBBKERA
09/23TEX7.0023152.57
09/17PHI6.0017351.50
09/11NYY5.00510159.00
09/04SFG6.0026473.00
08/29HOU7.0002340.00
Line Movement
Full Time
7.5 → 8.0 +0.5

Frequently asked questions

When was PHI @ NYM played?

This MLB game was played on 2026-09-17.

Where can I find the prediction for PHI @ NYM?

This ProbWin page shows the predictions our model published before the game (F5 and full-game totals, spreads), the key stats for both sides, and the settled result — every prediction is kept, win or lose, in our public track record.

How are these predictions calculated?

Our MLB statistical models are trained on league history and recomputed daily from team and player stats plus market odds. Every prediction is published before the game and its result is settled publicly.

GAMBLING PROHIBITED FOR MINORS. Gambling carries risks: debt, addiction, social isolation. Help & responsible play · BeGambleAware · GamCare: 0808 802 0133 · NCPG Helpline: 1-800-522-4700